Is your couples counselor sabotaging your marriage?

If you’ve Googled “How to fix a marriage” and called the first couples counselor that popped up, you may be setting yourself up for relationship derailment. And sooner or later, you might start asking yourself, Is your couples counselor sabotaging your marriage? More and more couples are coming to the same painful realization after spending hundreds of dollars and hours in therapy: this counseling is sabotaging their marriage. Here, let’s take the example of Sally, who couldn’t sleep; her husband was lying just inches away, yet he felt like a stranger.

She couldn’t even remember the last time they embraced, let alone made love, mostly because, by now, she didn’t really care anymore. The therapist she had dragged her “on-paper spouse” to had insisted they both dig deep and verbalize dark memories, painful perceptions, and unresolved hang-ups. At 3:00 a.m., the specific details escaped her. But the emotional weight? That had been gnawing at her gut ever since she sank into that therapist’s shiny leather couch.

Fixing a Broken Marriage - Is It Even Possible?

The “D” word was echoing in her ears…

The stats popping up online were not encouraging.

The National Survey of Family Growth projected the probability of a first marriage lasting 20 years was 52% for women and 56% for men.

Then came the real zingers. A Canadian study claimed lifelong singles had better overall health than married folks. An Italian study said their cancer rates were equal to or even lower. And the Australian one? That had her sucking harder on the last cigarette in her pack: lifelong single, childless women in their 70s had fewer major illnesses, healthier BMIs, and smoked less than married women.
Was she missing out? Should she chuck the whole marriage thing and dive into the swinging singles scene? Then… ding, an email popped up from her friend Maureen.

The energy in it was hard to miss: Maureen and Harry were going on a Caribbean
cruise to renew their vows. Wait, what? Sally was sure Maureen had once felt just like she did – like her couples counselor was sabotaging her marriage. Just a few months ago, at book club, Maureen practically bragged about using it as an escape from her husband. Sally made up her mind to call her the moment the sun rose.
That’s when she learned Maureen had been working with me, the Un-Talk Therapist. And suddenly, the questions started flying, from both ends of the line. Couples counseling? Without talking? You’ve got to be kidding! Sally said. That sounds counterintuitive – rebellious even.

Is Your Couples Therapist Secretly Sabotaging Your Relationship?

It might sound dramatic, but here’s a harsh reality: 3 out of 5 couples who follow traditional talk therapy still end up divorced. Maureen remembered how, back in the 1960s, breastfeeding advocates were seen as rebels. Today, every doctor and toddler alike knows that mother’s milk is gold for nutrition, immunity, and lifelong bonding. So much for playing it safe.

Maureen shared how I helped her and her husband build a brain science-based strategy to strengthen their marriage. With it, they could grow closer, boosting their emotional health and connection, on their own terms and timeline.
How?
They chose to break away from mainstream marriage therapy, the kind that says: “Let it
all out. Unleash the angst. Dump every passing feeling onto your partner preferably with
drama.” The slimier, the better.

Does marriage counseling work?

Believe it or not, sometimes marriage counseling “works,” just not in the way you’d hope. For some couples, it ends up driving the final nail into the marital coffin, convincing them their relationship isn’t worth saving. Instead of healing, it quietly encourages a split.

Studies show that nearly 25% of couples report their relationship worsened within two years after completing traditional talk therapy. Even more alarming? A staggering 38% end up divorced just four years after finishing their sessions, and draining their bank accounts.

Many therapists still lean on outdated Freudian models, urging couples to keep talking
things through endlessly. They become a constant presence, often inserting themselves
into the dynamic for months, even years, making you dependent on the therapy instead
of your partner.

Worse yet, they discourage you from holding back impulsive, emotional outbursts, labeling them “dishonesty.” But letting every thought fly isn’t authenticity; it’s sabotage. That unfiltered venting erodes the very foundation of meaningful communication.

What strengthens relationships isn’t yelling louder to be heard; it’s learning when not to speak. That’s where Un-Talk Therapy comes in. In Un-Talk Therapy, I help couples identify when, where, and why to talk, and just as crucially, when to stay silent or step back altogether. Backed by science and real results, this method replaces noise with clarity.

But a quick chat with couples who’ve embraced Un-Talk Therapy, and learned to balance their “lizard brain” with their “genius brain,” is usually enough to shift that thinking. With vivid visuals, smart humor, and simple brain science, I quickly get to the heart of the issue and craft a custom approach. Un-Talk Therapy doesn’t fix your relationship for you; it gives you just enough insight and direction to do what you already have the power to do. And that changes everything.

Here Comes the Un-Talk Therapy

In Un-Talk Therapy, I show you how to recognize, based on science, when to speak,
when to engage silently, and when it’s best not to interact at all. At first, most curious
couples are skeptical. How can learning brain science possibly help save a marriage in
just a few weeks?
But after just a brief chat with a couple who have successfully applied Un-Talk Therapy,
who now understand the dynamic between their “lizard brain” and their “genius brain,”
that doubt begins to shift.
With vivid visuals, clear definitions, and a little humor, whether in my office or over
Skype, I help couples cut to the chase and craft their custom healing path. Un-Talk
Therapy equips you with just enough insight to finally do what’s already within your
power: take back control of your relationship.

Change Your Brain, Change Your Relationship

What if the power to transform your relationship doesn’t lie in endless talking, but in how
your brain is wired? Thanks to the latest breakthroughs in brain science, we now know
something truly exciting: our brains aren’t fixed at birth. Through the discovery of
neuroplasticity, we’ve learned that those bundles of fat and water in our heads can be
rewired, and that means your emotional habits and mental patterns aren’t set in stone.
Sure, change isn’t easy. It takes awareness, effort, and a little training. But just like
you’d hire a coach to get your body in shape, it makes sense to have one for your mind
and your relationship, too. Every couple’s journey is unique, but the foundation of Un-
Talk Therapy remains the same: using the science of the brain to gently, purposefully,
reshape how you relate and reconnect.

What do I need to do to fix my relationship?

That’s a question I hear often. And here’s the truth: I can help change your mental diet,
but only if you bring five key ingredients to the table:

motivation: to stay together
desire: to enjoy each other again.
curiosity: about yourself and how your brain works.
willingness: to shift the way you communicate.
discipline: to practice, practice, and then practice some more.

As your Un-Talk Therapist, I bring my own essentials:

Simple, visual explanations of your brain in conflict.
Concrete steps to help your brain wean off its addiction to arguing.
Training on the importance of timing, yes, timing is everything.
A custom prescription for healthy communication.
And a healthy sense of humor to keep it real.

When you show up with your part, and I bring mine, you’re not just going to work, you’re
going to enjoy it.
You’ll begin to see your old conflicts in a whole new light. You might even laugh at the
patterns you once thought were permanent.
Take Sally, for example. In our very first session, she recounted the end of a long,
emotionally draining conversation. She remembered going completely speechless…
And then, something shifted.

She felt herself open up suddenly, seeing herself from a higher perspective. That’s
when Maureen asked her, “Can’t you think of a time when biting your tongue really paid
off?”
Sally was stunned. She couldn’t.

Can you?

What moment made you realize it?

Did it shift the emotional temperature in the room?

Do tell! I love hearing stories like these; they help me help others save their

relationships around the world.

Cheers to less talk and more love!

Phil

Philip DeLuca, MSW, LCSW

Couples Counselor & Relationship Expert | Matthews, North Carolina

To speak with Phil or inquire about individual counseling, give us a call or fill out the

contact form and click Send.

Have Question?